Steve's Progress with OCA
The first Module was Photography 1 - The Art Of Photography.
The second module was Photography 1 - Digital Photographic Practice - started in January 2012 and finished in May
Tuesday, 13 March 2012
Wednesday, 7 March 2012
Exercise 3.01 – Raw
The first image – daylight – was taken at the harbour.
440 mm, f/10, 1/160 sec
Adjustments made to the Raw image in Lightroom 3 were:
Exposure + 0.69
Highlight recovery + 22
Black Clipping +9 (to 14 from default of 5)
Clarity +52
Vibrance +49
White Balance Temperature + 253 to 5103
The local adjustment brush was used to darken the background, so accentuating the gull.
Adjustments made to the jpeg image in Lightroom 3 were:
Exposure + 0.32
Highlight recovery + 16
Fill light +7
Black Clipping +8
Clarity +22
Vibrance +10
White Balance Temperature +13 – Actual final temperature was not available.
It can be seen that adjustments in the Raw image were much higher than in the jpeg image for a similar result, so the adjustments in the Raw file are much more controllable. The colours in the Raw file look much more natural – the automatic in camera adjustments for the jpeg image have flattened the image slightly.
The second image – artificial light – was taken in my study, using overhead halogen spotlamps
28 mm, f/7.1, 1/5 sec
Adjustments made on the Raw image in Lightroom 3 were:
Exposure + 0.05
Highlight recovery +32
Clarity + 84
Saturation +3
The local adjustment brush was used, to select the vase and increase the exposure, contrast and clarity in that area.
The local adjustment brush was then used to select the white flowers and reduce the exposure and increase the clarity, saturation and contrast in that area – this was to show more detail in the flower petals.
Adjustments made to the jpeg file, also in Lightroom 3 were:
Clarity +68
Highlight recovery +43
The local adjustment brush was used to select the white flowers and decrease the exposure in that area.
Again, the adjustments to the Raw image required bigger steps, but that makes finer adjustments easier.
I was happy with the automatic white balance in the Raw image. That in the jpeg seemed slightly warm, but not too much.
There must have been some sharpening with the in-camera jpeg conversion as the petals of the white flowers in the jpeg image required less adjustment than the Raw file.
The final image – high dynamic range - was again taken in the harbour
175 mm, f/10, 1/500 sec
Adjustments made on the Raw image in Lightroom 3 were:
Exposure + 0.14
Highlight recovery +32
Clarity + 56
Vibrance +26
The local adjustment brush was used, to select the blue scaffolding lines above the station and darken them so they weren’t so prominent.
Adjustments made on the jpeg image in Lightroom 3 were:
Exposure -0.51
Highlight recovery +11
Black Clipping +3
Clarity + 40
Vibrance +40
The local adjustment brush was used, to select the blue scaffolding lines above the station and darken them so they weren’t so prominent.
The automatic White Balance worked well for this image. Both images work well, but I feel there’s more control in the highlight areas with Raw.
A more noticeable difference was noted when looking at the shadow areas in the two formats.
Both of these images have had their exposure increased by 3 stops, using Lightroom. The Raw image on the left can still bring out the colours and details across the whole range. The jpeg image on the right has lost all the detail in these shadow areas – it seems therefore that there’s a loss of data in the conversion.
We’ve seen advantages in using Raw over jpeg images.
· There’s no loss of data from the camera.
· The available amount of exposure compensation is far greater.
· The accuracy of any changes to the various parameters is far greater – so lots more control over how the image looks.
· Processing on the computer, rather than the camera means that there is more scope to produce the image required.
· Colours appear to be more accurate.
· White balance can be more easily and accurately changed.
· No loss due to sharpening
There are some disadvantages:
· It must be further processed and saved in another format before any print can be made.
· The files are much bigger – so more storage required.
· It takes more time and perseverance to create the final image.
Consider also the artefacts which may occur in jpeg images and the fact that further processing and saving as jpeg creates another loss of data.
Overall, I’m still convinced that Raw is the best way to take images – jpegs have their place, but I prefer to stay with Raw.
Saturday, 3 March 2012
Assignment 2 – Seeing like your camera
The four categories I’ve chosen for this assignment are:
1. Street scene in the middle of a clear, sunny day.
2. Early morning / late evening landscapes
3. Backlit scenes
4. Dappled light
1. Street scene
This first category was taken during the day on an unusually hot February afternoon.
The first two images were taken in the old town where the narrow streets can be very dark, so selecting those that run from North to South was essential for this exercise.
The third was taken in a relatively more modern street on the other side of town.
I used the Nikon D300s with 18 – 200 mm VR lens, without a tripod for these three images.
The exposure for the first image was measured using spot metering of the sky. This read f/9 at 1/250 sec. I wanted to make the dark areas darker and avoid any highlight clipping, hence the under exposure..
To maximize the contrast I shot into the South to emphasize the highlights and shadows.
This had the effect of making the buildings seem much darker, even those which were in sunlight, but I find the long shadows in this image appealing.
In composing this image I used the strong diagonal top right - bottom left and the direction of the shopper's shadows to create a leading line.
Taken further down the street, I wanted to emphasize the people in the street. Again, spot metering was used on the sunlit pavement and read f/9, 1/250 sec. I reduced the exposure to avoid highlight clipping and to darken the shadows.
Using a longer lens setting has shortened the perspective but made the street look busier.
Retaining the height of the buildings in the image gives a sense of place.
Because of the variations in light for this scene I used 3D matrix metering which suggested 1/400 sec. The rim lighting of the patient husband’s beard appealed to me here and also the chrome chairs / table. The shadowed area beyond the main subject was too light for my liking, hence the slight under exposure. Darkening this area makes him stand out.
I used a relatively wide aperture, as I wanted the figure to be isolated from the background.
2. Early morning / late evening landscapes
These three images were taken with the same camera / lens, but using a tripod. The early morning light lasts a long time at this time of year!
I used spot metering using the top of the lighthouse as the metering point and a small aperture to give a longer depth of field. The low sunlight gives a ‘warm’ look and creates a 3D view due to the shadows. The perspective with the red lighthouse increases this perception.
Positioning the lighthouse centrally was necessary to allow the perspective of the far pier.
Because of the variation in light conditions here I used 3D matrix metering. Without the low angle of the sun, the shadowed are does not get lit. I framed this to include the West pier lighthouse to enhance the perspective. A small aperture was used, to keep the lighthouse in reasonable focus.
This image and the previous one seem to have very vibrant colours – I suspect this is done in-camera during the JPEG conversion.
3D matrix metering was used here. I wanted to have a long depth of field, hence the small aperture. The long shadows from the side rails and pier stanchions, caused by the low sunlight have created a grid running down the length of the pier. The recessing verticals and the shadow grid give a sense of distance to the image. These vertical and horizontal lines and the receding curves were what I concentrated on in the composition. When the sun is higher the concrete area is in full shadow, so the grid and lighted verticals would not be so pronounced.
3. Backlit scenes
The following three images were taken over two days, with very different weather conditions. Again, they were all taken on the Nikon D300s, with the 18 – 200 mm VR lens and tripod mounted.
This image was taken from the lower level of the West pier with the sun just appearing over the East cliff and striking the top of the lighthouse. I used spot metering, with the metering point being the top of the lighthouse.
With the lighthouse positioned to the right of the image and the distant abbey on the left, there are several aspects of contrast here - tall / short, near / far and dark / light.
I accepted that there would be some highlight clipping where the sun was reflecting from the handrails and window, but this exposure would give me such a high contrast image that I was willing to sacrifice this small area.
I wanted to make this image a powerful one with lowering skies on this bleak moorland. The low cloud was in fact not as black as this looks, but the effect is what I was trying for. I hadn’t considered the reflections on the wet road, but I was happy when I saw the result.
I framed the image with the cross to the left, to create a lead into the scene.
I used spot metering to expose for the highlight areas in the sky – the auto exposure suggested f/25, 1/60 sec. As I wanted a darker image, I used the settings above.
This boundary stone sits on top of a round barrow. I set up the camera part way up the barrow and used spot metering with the sun as the metering point. In this case I kept the boundary stone to the right in the frame, with the sun to the left, again creating contrasts of large / small, near / far and dark / light.
I underexposed one stop, accepting that some clipping would occur, but wanting to retain some detail of the heather at the base of the stone. Using a longer lens setting made the sun slightly bigger in the frame while still keeping the boundary stone in frame.
4. Dappled Light
These images were taken in Sneaton forest. All were taken with the Nikon D300s, using the 18 – 200 mm VR lens and all were tripod mounted.
I used a wider aperture to enable a faster shutter speed, due to the low light conditions – I thought the reflected light would look better with the water movement ‘frozen’ rather than blurred lights.
In composing the image I wanted to use the water for the dappling, so I positioned the stone to the left and the leaves to the bottom of the frame while allowing the water to fill most of the frame, with movement from left to right.
I used 3D matrix metering due to the uncertainty of the best metering position in the constantly changing water.
Spot metering was used for this image, using the fungus as the metering point. The natural spotlighting of the fungus by the sun through the trees has made this an effective, high contrast image. Rim lighting on some of the trees adds interest to the scene. There is a small amount of highlight clipping, but I felt this was acceptable for the exposure.
When composing the image, I positioned the fungus in the lower part of the image and slightly to the right, to create a perceived line from dark to light. The contrasting vertical lines in the trees also accentuate the perceived dark to light movement.
I used centre weighted metering for this image – with the lighted bridge in the centre and uncertain lighting strength in the rest of the frame, it was the obvious choice. The exposure made the dark areas darker than I perceived them, but I think this improved the image.
The dappled light highlights the bridge and separates it from the dark area beyond. The dappled shadows on the path draw the eye to the bridge.
· If different weather conditions were used to alter the street shots, the scenes would be so changed, that the resemblance wouldn’t be shown – certainly there wouldn’t be people standing outside shops on dull, wet days.
· Taken on a dull day, the backlit scenes with less back lighting would show more detail in the dark areas but the impact of the silhouettes would be lost. It would be a shame to lose the impact on these images.
· For the dappled light section, retaking them on a dull day wouldn’t help the images as the contrast is what really makes them. Contrast could be increased as the sun gets stronger later in the year, or the leaf cover increases, but I don’t want to delay this assignment that long.
· The images that were taken in the early morning could be improved by showing more detail. This could be done when there’s more cloud cover. More detail would be seen in the shadows and the light areas would become darker, so less contrast but possibly more texture and interest.
Lower contrast images
The three images from the early morning category have been taken again, on an overcast day with occasional drizzle, using the same camera and lens, with 3D matrix metering. All images were taken as metered. The only post capture processing has been resizing.
The image is now much flatter, due to the lack of hard shadow. More detail can be seen in the stonework of the lighthouse and the pier. The colours are more muted.
Some shadow can still be seen here, but they are not as sharp. Colours are now muted and the image again looks too flat. The haze and drizzle have made the lighthouse almost non-existent in the image. Again, the original high contrast image is preferable.
With the hard shadows missing from the image, the stanchions now look very grey. The interesting shadow grid has receded due to the later time of day, but mainly the softer shadows don’t have the same impact, even though the sun is trying to break through. The haze and drizzle have now made the colours in the town fade.
With all three low contrast images, more detail can be seen in what were the shadow areas, but the earlier high contrast versions have much more vibrancy and depth. They have their place, particularly if detail enhancement software is used, but with the views taken I much prefer the earlier, livelier images.
I’d prefer to work with RAW and possibly HDR to get the best out of these images, but that of course is not in the remit for this assignment.
Evaluation:
Using exposure to control the highlight clipping I’ve seen that reducing the exposure reduces highlight clipping, reduces chromatic aberration, loses detail in the shadows and increases the colour saturation (to a limit). Increasing the exposure has the opposite effect, but increases the brightness.
I’ve seen the relationship between ISO setting and noise. I’ve also learned more about my camera’s settings for reducing high ISO and long exposure noise.
In calculating the camera dynamic range, I’ve learned that the lower ISO settings of my camera are derived by under exposing images, so better results are obtained at ISO 200 – the adjustment process clips the highlight detail significantly. I’ve learned some more about my camera. I’ll be using ISO 200 as the norm, unless I want slower shutter speeds than is reasonable at that setting.
I’ve seen that the scene dynamic range isn’t just a function of the contrasting colours, but of the intensity and direction of the light source. High contrast images will have these strong light sources and hard, dark shadows.
I’ve learned some quick fixes for correcting colour cast and seen that the white balance presets give a reasonable ‘guesstimate’ for a set condition. Auto white balance is a reasonable guess, but it may be possible to improve on it using software.
Reference material used in this section:
Books:
Perfect Exposure – Michael Freeman.
ISBN: 978-1-905814-46-6
The Digital SLR Handbook – Michael Freeman
ISBN-10: 1-904705-36-7
Langford’s Basic Photography – Michael Langford, Anna Fox and Richard Sawdon Smith
ISBN: 978-0-240-52168-8
The Focal Encyclopedia of Photography – Peres
ISBN-10:0-240-80740-5
Websites:
http://www.cambridgeincolour.com/tutorials/dynamic-range.htm