Steve's Progress with OCA

This blog is for the learning log for Steve Estill's progress in the study for the BA in Photography with OCA.

The first Module was Photography 1 - The Art Of Photography.
The second module was Photography 1 - Digital Photographic Practice - started in January 2012 and finished in May
For the third module see the new blog at http://moreocapnp.blogspot.co.uk/

Friday, 16 March 2012

Exercise 3.06 – Strength of interpretation

The first image I selected for this exercise was taken in St Mary’s Graveyard during the Goth festival. I feel that this image will suit a high contrast approach, even though there will be clipping in both highlights and shadows.

Exercise 3.06 01

Resting Goth

200 mm, 1/160 sec, f/6.3

I converted the Raw file to Tiff without any alterations to the original settings, then opened it in Photoshop.

In Photoshop I used a threshold adjustment layer to set the black and white points, then a curves adjustment layer with a very steep mid curve to create the high contrast colour image below:

Exercise 3.06 02

Some of the detail has been lost here and there’s obviously a significant amount of clipping. I’m not really taken with this version, but taking it into Black and White has a lot more potential. For this step I used the B&W adjustment layer.

Exercise 3.06 03

This version now works very well for me. There’s an entirely different feel to the image. What was an entertaining image has now become one portraying despair and loss.

For the second image I’ve chosen one of children playing in the sea. I considered this a good candidate for ‘high key’ treatment.

Exercise 3.06 04

Water babes

This was a very hazy day, so a lot of the background was very light before any adjustments. I converted the Raw file in Lightroom, increasing the exposure so that the background faded to white, then using the adjustment brush to lighten the foreground.

Exercise 3.06 05

This treatment certainly makes the water look more appealing. The remit was to lighten the whole image – I’d have been tempted to increase the contrast around the children to further enhance this image.

Taking the image into Black and White, using the Photoshop B&W adjustment layer has produced a more pleasing result, but I think the colour version could be better with that extra adjustment.

Exercise 3.06 06

I think this image works because of the horizontal line of children which stands out in the light background.

Exercise 3.05 – Black-and-white

The hill fog made this image feasible. For a long time I’ve known about these trees and how good they could look in the right conditions. Hill fog is often too wet to work in, but over the last couple of days we’ve had fog with quite dry conditions, so I was able to risk climbing down to capture this image.

I was sure it would work best in Black and White, particularly in foggy conditions when colours are muted anyway. The mist also gives a kind of aerial perspective (over a short distance) which gives an impression of depth. I wanted to use the wooden fence as a lead in to the scene and to give another impression of depth in the image. In fact there’s a physical depth to this image, as the ground falls away very sharply.

Exercise 3.05 01

20 mm, 1/20 sec, f/22.

This original image is quite flat. I composed it to use the fence as the lead in to the central tree, while keeping the hazy trees in frame. The branches closest to the camera would be much darker than those in the distance. The depth of colour in the bracken and sky will be similar and can be made much lighter in the black and white conversion.

Exercise 3.05 02

The image was first made more contrasty, using ‘levels’ and ‘curves’ adjustment layers, then a Black-and-white adjustment layer, where the sliders were adjusted to get this image.

I feel that this Black-and-white version works so much better than the colour version. It’s a much more powerful image than could have been expected from the colour version.

The elements of contrast, line and volume are used in the scene.

I got the image I set out to capture.

Wednesday, 14 March 2012

Exercise 3.04 – Interpretive processing

For this exercise I’ve used an image of the sanctuary in Castlerigg stone circle. The original Raw image was quite flat, due to the overcast weather conditions.
The first image is the first conversion to Tiff, using Adobe Raw within Photoshop. I reduced the exposure by 1.05 stops, increased the recovery by +95, increased the contrast to +40 and slightly reduced the clarity to -5.
Exercise 3.04 01 Castlerigg sanctuary
I felt this treatment recorded the feeling of the place.
I wanted to create an image that portrayed a mysticism, so I processed the image again – this time using Lightroom.
I increased the exposure by 0.25 stops, brightness to +76 and contrast to maximum. Clarity was reduced to -49, vibrance to -65 and saturation to -27. These settings created a fairly high key image with significantly reduced colour – I didn’t want completely monochrome as I felt this would detract from the ‘mystical’ quality I was looking for.
To further polarize the sanctuary I wanted to reduce the impact of the surrounding landscape, so I used a white vignette – again from Lightroom.
Exercise 3.04 02 Castlerigg mystical
Further additions could be made – a light on the centre stone, or an imported Druid, but I think this image does what I wanted.
For the third image I wanted to create a dark, foreboding feeling.
I opened the first image in Photoshop, duplicated the layer and treated it with Topaz Labs Adjust 5 plug in, in Charcoal sketch mode. I used ‘soft light’ blending mode (90% opacity) over the original layer, then stamped up the layers (Layer 1).
The burn tool was used to darken the sky in layer 1
A B&W adjustment layer was used to convert the image to monochrome and the layers again stamped up (Layer 2)
Layer 2 was placed in ‘lighten’ blending mode over Layer 1, then the image flattened.
Exercise 3.04 03 Castlerigg foreboding
This doesn’t look like a place you’d want to stay in for very long. A place where dark things may happen! Again, I retained some of the colour, but this time much darker.
I think I achieved my ideas in each of the images. I’m sure that they could each be further enhanced, but I’m happy with the results I obtained.

Project – Creative interpretation

Tuesday, 13 March 2012

Exercise 3.03 – Managing colour

Correction of colour casts is addressed in this exercise. Each image was taken in Raw with a high resolution jpeg copy. Obviously the jpeg file has had some ‘in-camera’ adjustments. Prior to correcting any of these images, my monitor was recalibrated, using a Gretag Macbeth Eye One, Display 2 calibrator

The first image was taken in our garden on a bright sunny day, but with the White Balance set for incandescent lighting to create the colour cast.

Exercise 3.03 01 jpeg

This jpeg image has a distinctly blue cast. The stone is a mid grey which will be used for reference.

Correction of this cast was done in a single stroke, using the ‘grey dropper’ tool accessed from a ‘Levels’ adjustment layer. Selecting the shadow area of the grey stone produced this correction:

Exercise 3.03 02 jpeg

No other adjustments were needed, as this is a good representation of the perceived colours on the day.

The Raw file was corrected for maximum dynamic range and saved as a tiff, as below:

Exercise 3.03 03 raw

In Adobe Raw, within Photoshop, the temperature was increased from 2950oK to 5500oK. Highlight recovery was increased and the blacks decreased to remove Highlight and Shadows Clipping. Clarity and Vibrance were increased. The resulting image was as below:

Exercise 3.03 04 raw

The raw file again provides a more controllable method of correction, but it obviously takes longer.

The second image was taken on a bright slightly hazy day with the White Balance again set for incandescent light. The jpeg image was as below:

Exercise 3.03 05 jpeg

The sky and sea, with the cast due to the white balance have made this image very blue indeed.

I had intended to use the concrete of the top of the pier as a reference point for the ‘grey dropper’ tool, but the correction didn’t work as well as the previous image – probably due to the sandy colour of the concrete – so a selective colour layer was used to further correct the cast:

Exercise 3.03 06 jpeg

This was an improvement, but still not to my satisfaction.

With the Raw image I had more chance of success:

Exercise 3.03 07 raw

Again, there’s a very blue cast to correct. In Adobe Raw I increased the Colour temperature from 2950 oK to 5300 oK, which improved the image considerably. I also increased the Highlight recovery, the Blacks, Contrast, Clarity and Vibrance. The Raw file was then saved as a Tiff file. A selective colour adjustment layer was used to further enhance the Red, Yellow and Green colours in the image, to produce the image below:

Exercise 3.03 08 raw

I’m much happier with the colours shown here, which are much closer to those seen at the time.

The third image was again captured in our garden. Taken on a very cloudy day with the White Balance set for fluorescent lighting to create a colour cast:

Exercise 3.03 09 jpeg

This image has a colour cast which is not as severe as the previous two, but it still needs some modification. The base of the concrete frog was used as target for the ‘grey dropper’ tool, which produced the following correction:

Exercise 3.03 10 jpeg

The colours in this image are very close to those seen at the time.

Using the Raw image, I decided to try to make the image look warmer than the above.

Exercise 3.03 11 raw

The above Raw image was opened in Adobe Raw and the colour temperature increased from 3950 oK to 4400 oK. Highlight recovery, Clarity, Vibrance and Saturation were increased and the image saved as a Tiff. A selective colour adjustment layer was then used to produce the ‘warmer’ tones below:

Exercise 3.03 12 raw

In this image you’d almost think the sun was breaking through!

So again, Raw files are much more controllable and generally produce better results than those available from jpeg files.

Exercise 3.02 – Managing tone

The image used for this exercise was taken on a slightly hazy but almost cloudless morning. Shooting away from the sun, to minimize shadows and increase the colour, I produced this low dynamic range, very flat image:

Exercise 3.02 01 jpeg

This jpeg image was opened in Photoshop where the exposure was reduced by one stop.

Using a ‘Levels’ adjustment layer with the Alt key depressed, the input black slider was moved to the right until the first indication of black was seen (at the curl of one of the waves).

Still with the Alt key depressed, the white slider was moved to the left until the first highlight clipping was seen (on a breaking wave).

This caused the blue sky to become too strong, so a black / white gradient was used in the layer mask with opacity of 40%, running from the top of the image to the first of the clouds. This reduced the effect of the levels adjustment layer.

A curves adjustment layer was then used to increase the mid-tone contrast, by creating an ‘S’ curve to lighten the highlight areas while holding back the darker parts:

image       image

A selective colour adjustment layer was then used to lighten the cyan and blue colours.

Exercise 3.02 02 jpeg

The raw image was then opened in The Adobe Raw editor in Photoshop.

Exercise 3.02 03 raw

The exposure and black sliders were increased until shadows and highlight clipping was seen. This also altered the colour balance, so the White Balance was adjusted, to reduce the impact of the strong sky. The clarity and contrast sliders were also used – this altered the highlight and shadow clipping, so the exposure / black sliders required more adjustment.

The brush tool was used to overexpose the now very dark sky and again to under expose and increase the clarity on the headland and village.

Exercise 3.02 04 raw

Generally I’d say that the raw image was more versatile, particularly with the use of the brushes in the Raw editor, and has produced a slightly better result. Much better control is available for image adjustments.

I’d make further colour adjustments in Photoshop proper, using a selective colour adjustment layer, but this exercise is aimed at the ‘tone’ control rather than ‘colour’.